Shopping and Switching Trends – Auto Insurance

Stakeholder(s):  CMO, Head Personal Lines, Advertising, Marketing, State Level Managers

Goal:  Track what percentage of current customers are actively shopping for auto insurance

LIST capabilities:

  • 5 years of shopping behavior history for auto insurance and 3 years for home/renters insurance
  • Competitive analysis
  • Ability to cut by demographic, segment, geography
  • Ability to overlay pricing data

Example insights:

  • Carrier has maintained a higher quote rate among their incumbents than the industry since 2020 with shopping peaking in Q4 2024 with 16.5% of incumbents shopping for a new policy
  • Carrier’s highest switch rate occurred in the same quarter (Q4 2024) with 6.9% of customers defecting to a new carrier

Already a LIST subscriber? Here is how to Replicate this Use Case.

For the industry lines: 

  • Columns: “Interval” in set to “Quarter”
  • Rows: (Found in the Auto Insurance Questions Tab) “Quote in the last 30 days” and “Did you switch to a new auto insurance company in the past 30 days” (percent “Yes” shown)

For the Carrier lines:

  • Filters: (Found in the Demographics tab) “Auto Incumbent Insurer” = Carrier
  • Columns and Rows same as above.

More Insights